Ignition Switch won’t stop Engine

Scotty

Member
Hi Folks, hoping I can get your guidance on a weird issue with my 3500S. Car is running well, but when hot, the engine will not switch off with the ignition switch; it just keeps running until I press the brake pedal, then it stops.
I recently replaced the ignition switch so it’s not that (hopefully!). I’ve checked the coil with a meter and with the engine off, the live feed works as it should based on the ignition switch on/off. With engine running however, I switch off the ignition and the coil feed is still live.
Fuses seem ok and the only thing I can find wrong is a broken wire on one of the front brake pads.
Any suggestions welcome and thanks in advance!
Scotty
 
Do you have a balast ignition?
If yes, then there is an additional feed to the coil from the starter. This should be live only when the starter operates, but perhaps in your case this is not connected correctly, or it is touching another live line.
 
Thanks Demetris, I’ll check that out. Lumenition system fitted long before my ownership. I’ll have a look next weekend and check out the starter wire. Thanks again.
 
I had the same happen when I fitted a fuel injection system to my car. It turns out there was a very small current from the alternator which was just enough to keep the main relay open when the ignition was turned off. Check the Lumenition system wiring to see if anything's live with the ignition off.
 
Hi Folks, hoping I can get your guidance on a weird issue with my 3500S. Car is running well, but when hot, the engine will not switch off with the ignition switch; it just keeps running until I press the brake pedal, then it stops.
I recently replaced the ignition switch so it’s not that (hopefully!). I’ve checked the coil with a meter and with the engine off, the live feed works as it should based on the ignition switch on/off. With engine running however, I switch off the ignition and the coil feed is still live.
Fuses seem ok and the only thing I can find wrong is a broken wire on one of the front brake pads.
Any suggestions welcome and thanks in advance!
Scotty
But of a wild thought but I wonder if there is back feed current from the alternator field coils via the warning light bulb which is connected by the white wire to the feed to the coil and presumably the lumenition unit , sufficient to keep it running the engine. Putting on the brake could be enough to short this through the brake lights to stop the process & thus stop the engine. `
 
But of a wild thought but I wonder if there is back feed current from the alternator field coils via the warning light bulb which is connected by the white wire to the feed to the coil and presumably the lumenition unit , sufficient to keep it running the engine. Putting on the brake could be enough to short this through the brake lights to stop the process & thus stop the engine. `

Hi, Yes I was thinking the same, only a slender connection with the operation of the brake light is enough to overcome it and the connection collapses. Does it do it with any other ignition controlled unit? I would say it's a dodgy diode in the alternator.

Colin
 
Thanks all, really appreciate the guidance as always. New alternator has been “on the list” for a while, so now might be the time! Cheers.
 
A very long-overdue update. Finally had some time this week to follow up on this issue. New alternator (ACR) sourced from Wins and fitted, but sadly the engine still won’t switch off. If I press the brake pedal or put on the indicators, the engine stops, so I suspect there is some back feed going on. Going by the state of the old alternator, the new one is a good investment regardless.
I’ve tried to test the other suggestions above, but have reached the limits of my electrical know-how. Last job is to clean the earth connections and possibly replace the Bosch relay next to the Luminition coil, seems like a low regret purchase. Then I guess an auto electrician or just keep pressing the brake pedal!
Will keep you posted.
 
I had a Mk4 Ford Escort that developed a similar fault, in my case I had to turn the headlights off to stop the engine! I suspect that something was somehow feeding back through the rear lights but I just lived with it.
 
Hello Harvey. New alternator was a direct swap for the ACR one that was there. The old one had a date of 1992 so I don’t know which one was there before that; before my ownership. Car is an 1974 with an C chassis number. Ignition switch was brand new.
Cheers.
 
Hi Folks, hoping I can get your guidance on a weird issue with my 3500S. Car is running well, but when hot, the engine will not switch off with the ignition switch; it just keeps running until I press the brake pedal, then it stops.
I recently replaced the ignition switch so it’s not that (hopefully!). I’ve checked the coil with a meter and with the engine off, the live feed works as it should based on the ignition switch on/off. With engine running however, I switch off the ignition and the coil feed is still live.
Fuses seem ok and the only thing I can find wrong is a broken wire on one of the front brake pads.
Any suggestions welcome and thanks in advance!
Scotty

First, what do we mean by saying that the engine keeps running? Is it just as if you left the ignition on, or does the character of the engine noise seem to change after shutting off the ignition switch? let's eliminate the ignition switch. If the ignition is off, all power to the coil and distributor should be shut down. If not, then the power must be getting through to the coil., and thence on to the distributor.

If we find that source we need to determine if something is amiss with the wiring or the involved unit itself. The wiring diagram shows two possible sources for the ignition coil. Wire one is the power leg of fuse #62. This is the one that is active under normal driving conditions. But, there is another source, and that would be the wire that runs to the ignition from the solenoid. During starting (starter motor active) a line from the starter solenoid bypasses the ballast resistor and gives its full power to the coil. This is because when starting, the load on the starter lowers all voltage in the system, and it fails to fire the coil properly. Again, the purpose of this secondary source is to bypass the ballast resistor, thus giving full battery voltage to the coil and 'reviving' the needed voltage/amperage to fire it and the distributor. Hmm. Two possible sources...so far.

The car will run fine on either source, but when you release the ignition switch to the 'run' position, the boost from eliminating the ballast resistor should drop away, leaving the ballasted coil to run the show. You should also understand the ballast principle of coil function. Coils for 12 volt ballasted systems are usually made to run on 6 to 9 volts. When the resistor is temporarily bypassed, the required voltage is still present, despite the load imposed by the starter. When the starter has done its job and you let go of the key, the starter load is gone, and the normal driving mode is attained at that 6-9 volts (through the ballast resistor). So, how does that relate?

Well, it could be that the ballast resistor wire from the solenoid stays hot, even if you let go of the key. This could mean a wiring fault, or contacts within the solenoid are stuck. Generally, this is not the cause of your problem, but I'm not there.. Let the engine run up to warm or so and touch the ballast resistor to see if it's excessively hot. It may still be active and running at increased voltage. If so, we can be pretty sure it's getting voltage when it should not. This sounds just fine until you realize that the resistor will burn up eventually. How long? Who knows? Lots of things factor in here, and I've seen a car run for months or even years on just the hot voltage from the solenoid. Others will burn out within a minute. Like I say, lots of factors.. There's a way to check that.

While the engine is running, disconnect the 'boost wire' ( NOT the normal running wire!) that runs to the ballast (distributor end) from the solenoid. If the engine continues running on ballasted power after disconnecting that wire, the starting up system is likely working, but if it stalls immediately, it has been running on 'boost power' (no ballast resistor involved) If this happens, you most likely have a wiring problem or a bad solenoid.

But, to get into that, I will need to explain a lot of stuff that relates to the wiring diagram itself. Please answer the question about the character of running sound after switching off. Also, What idle speed does the tachometer show? Does it or other instruments change when you shut the key off?

You indicate that the engine continues to run, but then you write later that the problem begins only when you start the car. So, when does the engine 'recover' from this condition? Only when you step on the brake? Or, eventually by itself? How long does the engine continue to run if you leave the brake pedal alone? The brake pedal thing seems possible, but not a certainty.

Do you have a workshop manual or access to one? I found one online through Google. Many a non-professional mechanic has no clear idea of what goes on electrically in these cars. They are complex, and frankly, needlessly so. I worked in the late sixties and early seventies for one of the first dealers of these cars, and I have seen some mighty strange things go on with them; too many to list! I've loved and owned several of them (2000s) and had a 'flock' of customers which I inherited when that dealer went out of business. I also have a dealer's tool board with all the special tools present, plus a few duplicates! (not pertinent, but nice to recall)

One strange example of starter/ run issues: We had in a 1970 3500s that would sit quietly for fifteen minutes or so and then suddenly start up and sit there patiently waiting for someone to drive it or shut it off! It drove us crazy untill we discovered that when the clock winder triggered, the car would start. I cannot remember the remedy, but we did eventually discover its curse. (Incidently, this can be quite dangerous, because the steering lock stays engaged.) The point is that because they are so needlessly complicated, it becomes a mind numbing experience trying to figure out the seemingly endless permutations and possibilities. If you're working without a paper manual, you are truly handicapped. See if you can at least get a printed out version of the diagram and the key. We'll do better that way, I'm sure. And don't worry, we'll get it!

A sudden thought occurs: How are your brake lights working? One of the things that runs off of that #62 fuse is the brake light switch. You indicate that stepping on the brake shuts the engine off. How quickly? You may have a short in the brake lamp wiring or switch that causes the voltage to drop precipitously or completely, and that may be enough to stop the engine. Have someone stand behind the car with it running. Now shut the igition switch. If things are as suspected, the brake lights may come on dimly and briefly or not at all. Then the engine stalls. If so, you have a short in the brake wiring or switch, and that just may not be the cause of thee running 'continuation'. Try disconnecting the brake lamps at the switch and see what happens. Unfortunately, there are other possibilities. But we need to bring more information to the table. You also say that you recently replaced the ignition switch. Was the problem present before you installed the new one? Check those connections again!

Yes, these electrical systems are full of gremlins. Such are those days between standard carburation and fuel injection. The electrical engineers went nuts!

I'll help if you like, or leave you alone like any other annoyance. Just tell me..
 
Hi Bill, thanks for your comprehensive notes, much appreciated. I’ll try some of your suggestions over the next few days.
I do have a manual and wiring diagram. I’ll check again, but I’m pretty sure the wire from the solenoid to the coil goes via a Bosch relay on my car. That could be a previous modification. The wiring diagram suggests it goes to a resistor but I can’t find one. Engine behaves as normal when the ignition switch is turned off and just keeps running. The red warning light comes on as you would expect when the ignition is turned off and the ignition controlled dials and switches stop working. The engine stops when I press the brake pedal or turn on the indicators.
The problem existed prior to the new ignition switch being fitted.
I’ll do some more detective work and testing as you suggest and respond again in due course.
Thank again meantime.
 
I think that the problem lies not with the ignition circuit but the other side of the fault. It's picking up a feed from somewhere which is fragile, it's enough to keep the engine running but not the brake or indicator lights, so the connection fails. The brake lights are just a simple switch but the indicators have more components involved so try looking there. Try disconnecting flasher cans, my first place would be the hazard switch, it is a complicated switch involving ignition (fused) and battery supply, It is so little used that the contacts corrode and the slightest touch can break the connections within, so operate it a number of times and if you can use switch cleaner.

Colin
 
IMG_2078.jpegIMG_2077.jpegQuick update. More still to do.
Have cleaned hazard switch and flasher unit and also tried disconnecting flasher unit. No change but both benefited from a good clean with contact cleaner.
Have attached a couple of photos following Bill‘s note showing the Lumenition set up. The white/yellow wire (arrowed) from the solenoid goes to a Bosch relay next to the coil, then a brown wire goes from the relay to the coil. The red wire is an ignition-controlled feed from the fuse box to the relay, then onward to the Lumenition unit. Both red wire and white/yellow seem to be working as you would expect when ignition is on, but not live when ignition is off.
It seems like I have the Lumenition version which does not have a ballast resistor. Resistance across the coil is 1.2 ohms.
I tested the positive coil terminal when the ignition was off but with the engine still running. Coil was live as Bill said.
I haven’t yet tried disconnecting the solenoid wire to see if that makes a difference. Is there any risk in doing that or is it a low regret option?
Lastly, ignition switch and fuse box seem fine. Not sure.
Meanwhile, I’ll keep pressing the brakes or putting on the indicators to stop the engine!
 
I wonder if there is enough current through the bulb to hold the coil contacts closed with the ignition off . Try switching the ignition off , leaving the engine running and pull off the black earth wire on the relay to see if it stops the engine .
 
Tried that this afternoon and yes, pulling off the black wire from the relay stops the engine!! Any hints on what to do next gratefully received!
Thank you.
 
Back
Top